Individual Trustee vs Corporate Trustee for an SMSF: A Practical Comparison
When setting up a self-managed super fund (SMSF), one of the first decisions you need to make is whether to use individual trustees or a corporate trustee.
It might seem like a simple administrative choice, but it can have a significant impact on how your fund operates over the years. It affects the cost of running your SMSF, how assets are held, what happens when a member dies or leaves, and how easily the fund can deal with changes in membership.
An individual trustee structure is generally cheaper to establish. A corporate trustee costs more initially and has an ongoing ASIC fee, but it can make managing the fund considerably easier over the long term.
So which option is right for you?
Let's look at the differences and the situations where each structure makes sense.
Individual trustee vs corporate trustee: What's the difference?
An SMSF can have either individual trustees or a company acting as trustee.
With individual trustees, the members of the fund generally act as trustees personally. With a corporate trustee, a company holds the fund's assets and the members act as directors of that company.
The distinction is important because the trustee is legally responsible for managing the fund and ensuring it complies with superannuation law.
Here's a quick comparison:
Factor | Individual trustees | Corporate trustee |
|---|---|---|
Who acts as trustee? | Each member personally | A company controlled by the members |
Single-member SMSF | Generally requires a second individual trustee | Member can be sole director |
Ownership of assets | Held in trustees' personal names as trustees | Held in the company's name |
Member joins or leaves | Assets generally need to be re-titled | Director details change; asset titles remain |
Death of a member | May require a change to trustee arrangements | Company continues to operate |
Administrative penalties | Can apply to each individual trustee | Generally imposed once on the company |
Property borrowing | May limit lender options | Commonly preferred by lenders |
Establishment costs | Lower | Higher |
Ongoing costs | Generally lower | Includes annual ASIC fees |
The cheapest option at establishment is not necessarily the cheapest option over the life of the fund.
1. Individual trustees: Lower initial costs, but more administration
Under an individual trustee arrangement, the members of the SMSF act as trustees in their personal capacity.
The trustees are responsible for managing the fund, making investment decisions and ensuring that the SMSF complies with the relevant legislation and its trust deed.
An SMSF can have up to six members, with the trustee arrangements needing to satisfy the relevant superannuation rules.
The difficulty with single-member funds
Individual trustee arrangements can be awkward for single-member SMSFs.
Generally, a single-member fund needs a second individual trustee. That person must meet the applicable eligibility requirements and may be a relative of the member or another eligible person.
This means the member has to involve someone else in the administration of their retirement savings.
The second trustee may need to sign investment decisions, minutes and other fund documents, even though they have no financial interest in the SMSF.
A corporate trustee avoids this complication because a single member can generally act as the company's sole director.
Changing trustees can become expensive
One of the biggest disadvantages of individual trustees is what happens when a member joins or leaves the fund.
Because the assets are held in the names of the individual trustees, a change in the trustee group generally means the legal ownership details of the fund's assets need to be updated.
This can involve bank accounts, shareholdings, investment platforms and property titles.
Each institution or registry may have its own forms and procedures. If the fund owns property, the process can be more involved and may require additional legal and state revenue office documentation.
For a small SMSF holding cash and a simple share portfolio, this may not be a major issue. However, it becomes more complicated when the fund owns several investments or property.
When do individual trustees make sense?
Individual trustees can still be a reasonable option in certain circumstances, particularly where:
The SMSF has two members in a stable relationship.
The fund holds a relatively simple portfolio of cash and listed shares.
There are no plans to borrow to purchase property.
Membership is unlikely to change.
The members expect to wind up the fund within a relatively short period.
In these situations, avoiding company registration and annual ASIC fees may make financial sense.
However, if the fund is expected to operate for many years, it is worth considering the longer-term administrative costs.
2. Corporate trustees: More expensive to establish, but more flexible
With a corporate trustee, a company is established to act as trustee of the SMSF.
The members generally become directors of the company, and the company holds legal title to the fund's assets.
The biggest advantage is that the company continues to hold the assets even when the membership or directorship changes.
For example, if one member leaves the SMSF and another joins, the company remains the legal owner of the fund's investments. The relevant director details are updated, but the assets generally do not need to be transferred into different names.
This can save considerable administration over the life of the fund.
Why use a special purpose company?
Most SMSF corporate trustees are established as special purpose companies.
These companies are set up specifically to act as trustee of a regulated superannuation fund. Provided the company meets the relevant requirements, it qualifies for a reduced ASIC annual review fee.
Using a dedicated company also helps keep the SMSF's assets separate from the risks associated with a member's trading business.
Using an existing trading company as trustee is generally not recommended. It can complicate the structure, create unnecessary exposure to business risks and result in the loss of the reduced ASIC fee.
A separate company established solely for the SMSF is usually the cleaner arrangement.
What are the responsibilities of a corporate trustee?
A corporate trustee does not remove the members' responsibilities.
Directors must still ensure that the SMSF complies with superannuation law and the trust deed. They also have obligations under the Corporations Act.
The company must maintain its ASIC registration, keep its details up to date and meet its annual review requirements.
Every director must also hold a director identification number (Director ID) and meet the relevant eligibility requirements.
Each new director must sign the ATO trustee declaration within the required timeframe.
In other words, a corporate trustee provides a more flexible structure, but it does not make the SMSF any less subject to compliance obligations.
3. What happens when a member dies?
Succession planning is one of the strongest reasons to consider a corporate trustee.
Under an individual trustee arrangement, the death of a member can create additional administration.
For example, if an SMSF has two individual trustees and one dies, the surviving trustee may be left needing another eligible trustee or a change to a corporate structure.
The fund also needs to consider how the deceased member's benefits will be dealt with and who has authority to make decisions.
Under a corporate trustee, the company continues to own the fund's assets. The change generally involves dealing with the directorship rather than transferring every asset into new names.
This can make the process more straightforward, particularly where the fund holds property or several investments.
Blended families need to plan carefully
Succession becomes especially important where members have children from previous relationships or a second spouse.
Control of the corporate trustee can influence who makes decisions about the fund and how death benefits are dealt with.
Trustees should consider the company constitution, the process for appointing directors and their estate planning arrangements.
A properly prepared binding death benefit nomination can also help ensure that the member's intentions are documented.
The important point is that the trustee structure and estate planning documents should work together. A corporate trustee does not automatically guarantee that a member's wishes will be followed.
4. What about ATO penalties?
There can also be an important difference in how administrative penalties apply.
Where an SMSF has individual trustees, administrative penalties can be imposed on each individual trustee.
For example, a fund with two individual trustees may face two penalties for a single contravention.
With a corporate trustee, the penalty is generally imposed once on the company rather than separately on every director. The directors can still be jointly and severally liable for the company's penalty.
This does not mean a corporate trustee protects directors from all personal responsibility. Directors remain responsible for their conduct and can still face consequences where they cause or allow a breach.
However, the difference in how administrative penalties are applied is worth considering when deciding on the structure.
You can read more about the types of problems that can lead to penalties in our guide to common SMSF compliance breaches.
5. Buying property through an SMSF
If your SMSF intends to borrow money to purchase property, a corporate trustee is generally the more practical option.
Under a limited recourse borrowing arrangement (LRBA), the property is held in a separate holding trust until the loan is repaid.
Many lenders offering SMSF loans commonly require a corporate trustee. They may also require a corporate custodian for the holding trust.
Using individual trustees can therefore restrict your lender options or require a restructure before the property purchase can proceed.
This is particularly relevant for business owners considering purchasing their commercial premises through their SMSF.
There are additional rules where an SMSF purchases business real property from a related party or leases property to a related business.
Our guide to selling business real property into an SMSF explains some of the important requirements.
6. What does a corporate trustee cost?
The main disadvantage of a corporate trustee is the additional cost.
Typical expenses include:
ASIC company registration when the company is established.
An annual ASIC review fee, generally at the reduced special purpose company rate.
Professional fees for company registration and preparation of an appropriate constitution.
Any legal or accounting costs associated with establishing the structure.
Director IDs do not carry a government application fee.
ASIC fees are adjusted periodically, so it is important to check the current amounts.
Individual trustees avoid the company registration and annual ASIC fees. However, costs can arise later when trustees change and assets need to be re-titled.
There may also be registry fees, legal costs and potential stamp duty considerations, depending on the assets involved and the state or territory.
The corporate trustee therefore costs more upfront, but the additional expense may be worthwhile if the fund is expected to operate for many years.
For a more detailed breakdown, see our article on what it costs to set up and run an SMSF.
7. Which trustee structure is right for your SMSF?
There is no single answer for every fund. The decision depends on the number of members, the investments held, whether borrowing is planned and how long the SMSF is expected to operate.
Your circumstances | Structure worth considering |
|---|---|
Couple with a simple share portfolio | Either structure may work |
Single-member SMSF | Corporate trustee |
Blended family | Corporate trustee |
Planning to borrow for property | Corporate trustee |
Adult children may join later | Corporate trustee |
Fund likely to wind up within a few years | Individual trustees may be suitable |
Consider a couple in their fifties with an SMSF holding listed shares and cash. Individual trustees may be perfectly adequate today.
However, if they plan to purchase commercial property in five years, or expect adult children to join the fund later, a corporate trustee may be the better long-term choice.
Converting to a corporate trustee later is possible, but it involves additional paperwork and changing the ownership details of the fund's assets.
For a fund expected to operate for decades, it is often worth considering the structure that will work best in the future, not just the cheapest option today.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between an individual and corporate trustee?
Individual trustees hold the fund's assets in their personal names as trustees. A corporate trustee is a company that holds the assets, with the members generally acting as directors. A corporate trustee costs more but usually makes changes to membership and succession easier.
Can a single-member SMSF have an individual trustee?
A single-member SMSF using individual trustees needs a second eligible individual trustee. A corporate trustee allows the sole member to act as the company's sole director, subject to the relevant requirements.
Does a corporate trustee reduce SMSF penalties?
Administrative penalties are generally imposed once on a corporate trustee, rather than separately on each individual trustee. However, directors can still be personally liable and remain responsible for compliance.
Can I change from individual trustees to a corporate trustee?
Yes. The trust deed must permit the change, the company must be established, the trustee appointment must be properly documented and the ATO must be notified. The fund's assets and accounts will also need to be updated where required.
Does a corporate trustee reduce the tax payable by an SMSF?
No. The trustee structure does not change the SMSF's tax rates, contribution caps or pension rules. Both structures are subject to the same superannuation and taxation requirements.
Need help choosing the right SMSF structure?
Choosing between individual and corporate trustees is an important decision. While individual trustees can save money initially, a corporate trustee may provide greater flexibility and make the fund easier to manage as circumstances change.
At Guidance Accounting, we help SMSF trustees understand their compliance obligations and make informed decisions about their fund's structure and ongoing administration.
Our SMSF Support Package provides ongoing compliance support, including financial statements, annual return preparation and coordination of the independent audit.
If you are establishing an SMSF or considering changing your existing trustee structure, contact Guidance Accounting to discuss your circumstances.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general information purposes only and should not be relied upon as financial, taxation or legal advice. SMSF trustee requirements, company obligations and state-based duty rules can vary depending on individual circumstances. Trustees should obtain professional advice before establishing or changing an SMSF structure. Guidance Accounting accepts no responsibility for decisions made solely on the basis of this article.