SMSF Binding Death Benefit Nominations: Questions Trustees Ask
An SMSF binding death benefit nomination can make a significant difference to what happens to your superannuation when you die. It allows you to direct the trustee to pay your superannuation death benefit to specific beneficiaries, in the proportions you choose.
However, getting the nomination right is essential. A nomination that does not comply with the fund's trust deed may be invalid, leaving the trustee to decide who receives the benefit. That can create uncertainty, family disputes and potentially unexpected tax consequences.
There is also an important distinction between SMSFs and larger superannuation funds. Following the High Court decision in Hill v Zuda Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 21, the familiar three-year expiry rule does not automatically apply to SMSF nominations. Whether a nomination expires depends on what the fund's trust deed and the nomination itself say.
Let's look at the questions SMSF trustees commonly ask and what you need to consider.
What is a binding death benefit nomination?
A binding death benefit nomination (BDBN) is a written direction from an SMSF member telling the fund's trustee who should receive their superannuation death benefit and how it should be divided.
If the nomination is valid when the member dies, the trustee must follow those instructions. This removes the trustee's discretion over the distribution, provided the nominated beneficiaries are legally eligible and the nomination meets the requirements of the trust deed.
It is important to understand that superannuation generally sits outside your Will unless the death benefit is directed to your legal personal representative. This means your Will does not automatically determine who receives your SMSF balance.
There are three arrangements that are often confused:
Binding death benefit nomination: A valid direction that the trustee must follow.
Non-binding nomination: A statement of the member's wishes. The trustee considers it but retains discretion over the final decision.
Death benefit agreement or member-specific rule: Some SMSF deeds allow members and trustees to enter into specific agreements or establish rules for how a member's benefit is to be dealt with. These arrangements must also be permitted by the deed.
The important point is that the fund's trust deed determines which arrangements are available and how they must be made.
What happens if there is no binding nomination?
Without a valid binding nomination, the trustee generally decides how the death benefit is distributed, subject to superannuation law and the trust deed.
The benefit can generally be paid to the deceased member's dependants or their legal personal representative. The trustee must determine who is eligible and how the benefit should be divided.
This can become complicated in an SMSF because the people controlling the fund may also be potential beneficiaries.
For example, consider a two-member SMSF where a husband and wife are both directors of the corporate trustee. If the husband dies, the wife may become the sole remaining director and have control over the trustee's decision.
The deceased member's legal personal representative may also be appointed as a trustee or director in certain circumstances under section 17A of the SIS Act. This can mean an executor becomes involved in decisions about the distribution.
If the family agrees, this process may work without difficulty. However, in blended families or situations involving children from previous relationships, competing interests can quickly lead to disputes.
Funds that have added adult children as SMSF members may also have additional people involved in decisions about the deceased member's benefit.
Does every SMSF member need a binding nomination?
Not necessarily. However, a binding nomination can be particularly valuable where family circumstances or the structure of the fund make the distribution of benefits more complicated.
It is worth considering where:
You have a blended family: You may want to ensure children from an earlier relationship receive a specific share rather than leaving the decision to a surviving spouse.
You want greater certainty: A valid nomination can reduce the scope for disagreement about who should receive your superannuation.
Your SMSF owns business property: Where the fund owns commercial property leased to a family business, the death of a member can affect the wider business and succession arrangements.
You have a single-member SMSF: The person who takes control of the trustee after your death may not know or understand your intentions.
Tax outcomes matter: Directing benefits to a spouse or another eligible tax dependant may produce a different tax result from paying an independent adult child.
Even couples with straightforward family arrangements may benefit from having nominations in place. It can provide certainty if both members die close together or if circumstances change unexpectedly.
Who can receive an SMSF death benefit?
A binding nomination cannot direct superannuation to just anyone. The nominated recipient must generally be either an eligible dependant under superannuation law or the member's legal personal representative.
Eligible dependants include:
A spouse or de facto partner, including a same-sex partner.
A child of any age, including stepchildren and adopted children.
A person in an interdependency relationship with the member.
Someone who was financially dependent on the member.
The member's legal personal representative is generally the executor named in their Will or an administrator appointed where there is no Will.
Importantly, eligibility is assessed at the date of death, not when the nomination is signed.
For example, a member may nominate their spouse in 2019 but subsequently divorce. If the former spouse is no longer an eligible dependant when the member dies, the nomination may fail in relation to that person.
How does the beneficiary affect tax?
Being eligible to receive a superannuation death benefit does not automatically mean the recipient will receive it tax-free.
Tax law uses a narrower definition of dependant than the rules governing who can receive the benefit.
Beneficiary | General tax treatment of a lump sum |
|---|---|
Spouse or de facto partner | Tax-free |
Child under 18 | Tax-free |
Financially dependent or interdependent adult child | Tax-free |
Financially independent adult child | Tax may apply to the taxable component |
Legal personal representative | Depends on the people who ultimately benefit from the estate |
For a financially independent adult child, the taxable component may be taxed at up to 15% plus the Medicare levy on the taxed element, and up to 30% plus the levy on the untaxed element.
The tax-free component of the member's superannuation balance remains tax-free regardless of the recipient.
This is why the choice of beneficiary should not be treated as simply an estate planning decision. It can also affect the amount of tax paid by the family.
Death benefit arrangements should form part of a broader review of potential SMSF tax leakage.
How do you make a binding nomination valid?
The starting point is always the SMSF trust deed.
The deed determines whether binding nominations are permitted and the formal requirements that must be followed. Many deeds adopt requirements similar to those in SIS regulation 6.17A, even though that regulation does not automatically apply to SMSFs.
A nomination should not simply be downloaded from the internet and signed without checking the deed.
The following checklist covers the main issues trustees should consider:
Check the trust deed: Confirm that the current deed allows binding nominations and identify the relevant clause.
Identify eligible beneficiaries: Make sure each nominated person is legally eligible to receive the benefit.
Specify the percentages: Clearly state the proportion each beneficiary should receive. The percentages should total 100%.
Sign and date the document: The member must sign personally, unless the deed and any relevant power of attorney allow an attorney to act.
Arrange witnesses: Where the deed requires it, two eligible witnesses must be present when the member signs. They must meet the deed's requirements and cannot be nominated beneficiaries.
Give the nomination to the trustee: Make sure it is formally delivered and that receipt is recorded.
Check the expiry provisions: Confirm whether the nomination lapses and, if so, when it needs to be renewed.
Check other estate planning documents: Make sure the nomination is consistent with any reversionary pension arrangements and the member's Will.
Keep the original safely: Store the signed document with the fund's permanent records and retain evidence of any earlier nominations being revoked.
One commonly overlooked step is actually delivering the signed nomination to the trustee.
A document signed and stored at home may not satisfy the deed's requirements if it has never been formally given to the trustee. Even where the member is also a director of the corporate trustee, recording receipt in a dated trustee minute provides useful evidence.
Good record keeping is an important part of SMSF administration and can help avoid common SMSF compliance problems.
Do SMSF binding nominations expire after three years?
This is one of the most common questions trustees ask.
The short answer is no, not automatically.
In Hill v Zuda Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 21, the High Court confirmed that the requirements in section 59(1A) of the SIS Act and regulation 6.17A do not apply to SMSFs.
As a result, an SMSF binding nomination does not automatically expire after three years simply because of the general rule that applies to many larger superannuation funds.
However, there is an important qualification.
Some older SMSF trust deeds were drafted to include a three-year expiry requirement. If your deed contains that provision, the nomination may still expire after three years.
The wording of the current trust deed is therefore critical. Trustees should not assume that a nomination is permanent simply because of the High Court decision.
Even where a nomination does not expire, it should be reviewed whenever there is a significant change in the member's circumstances.
Marriage, divorce, remarriage, the birth of grandchildren, children becoming financially independent or changes to business ownership can all affect whether an existing nomination remains appropriate.
What are the disadvantages of a binding nomination?
A binding nomination provides certainty, but that certainty can also be a disadvantage.
Once a valid nomination is in place, the trustee must generally follow it. The trustee cannot simply change the distribution because circumstances have changed or because another arrangement now appears more appropriate.
For example, a member may nominate an adult child who is financially independent. Years later, the child may be experiencing financial difficulties, while another family member has become financially dependent on the deceased. The trustee may still be required to follow the original nomination.
The main differences are:
Certainty: A binding nomination fixes the intended outcome, while trustee discretion leaves the decision open.
Flexibility: A trustee exercising discretion may consider changed circumstances. A binding nomination generally cannot be adjusted after death.
Tax: A nomination can lock in a distribution that may not produce the most favourable tax outcome at the time of death.
Disputes: A binding nomination may reduce arguments about the intended distribution, but disputes can still arise over whether the document is valid.
Maintenance: Nominations need to be reviewed after major life events and changes to the trust deed.
The best approach depends on the member's family circumstances, the fund's assets and the level of certainty they want.
What have court cases told us about binding nominations?
Several court decisions demonstrate why the wording and execution of a nomination matter.
Munro v Munro [2015] QSC 61
In this case, the nomination directed the benefit to the trustee of the deceased estate rather than using the legally recognised term, legal personal representative. The nomination was held to be invalid.
The lesson is that seemingly minor drafting errors can have significant consequences.
Wooster v Morris [2013] VSC 594
This case involved a surviving spouse who controlled the trustee and resisted paying a death benefit to the deceased member's daughters. The Supreme Court of Victoria upheld the validity of the nomination.
It demonstrates that a valid binding nomination can be enforced even where the surviving trustee disagrees with the member's instructions.
Hill v Zuda Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 21
This High Court decision clarified that the general three-year lapsing rule does not automatically apply to SMSFs. The trust deed determines whether a nomination expires.
Together, these cases highlight why trustees should have their nominations checked against the actual governing rules of their fund.
What takes priority: a reversionary pension, the Will or a binding nomination?
These documents can interact, and it is important that they are coordinated.
A Will does not generally control superannuation unless the death benefit is paid to the member's legal personal representative.
A reversionary pension is different. It may provide that an existing pension continues to an eligible beneficiary after the member's death.
Whether a reversionary pension takes priority over a binding nomination depends on the trust deed and the relevant pension documents. Some deeds give the reversionary pension priority, while a nomination may apply to any remaining balance.
There are three areas worth checking:
Beneficiary details: The pension documents, nomination and Will should be consistent with the member's overall estate planning intentions.
Transfer balance cap: A reversionary pension is generally counted towards the recipient's transfer balance cap 12 months after the member's death. A new death benefit pension established following a nomination is generally counted immediately.
Payment through the estate: Directing the benefit to the legal personal representative means it is paid through the estate. This may allow testamentary trust planning, but can also expose the benefit to estate claims and creditors.
These arrangements should be reviewed together rather than treated as separate documents.
Is there an ATO binding death benefit nomination form?
No. The ATO does not provide a standard binding death benefit nomination form specifically for SMSFs.
This is because the nomination is governed by the SMSF's trust deed, rather than a universal ATO form.
Forms available from large superannuation funds are generally designed for those funds and their own governing rules. They may not be suitable for an SMSF.
Trustees may obtain forms from their deed supplier, administration software provider or an online legal document service. More complex situations, such as blended families, substantial superannuation balances or business assets, may require a lawyer to prepare the nomination.
Whatever option you choose, the document should be checked against the current trust deed.
Your SMSF compliance process should also include checking whether a nomination is on file, whether it remains valid and whether it is consistent with any recent deed changes. Guidance Accounting's SMSF compliance services can help identify administrative issues that need attention.
Other questions SMSF trustees ask
What happens if a nominated beneficiary dies before the member?
The nomination may fail in relation to that beneficiary. Depending on the wording of the deed and nomination, the affected share may fall back to trustee discretion or the entire nomination could be invalid.
A properly drafted fallback provision can help avoid uncertainty.
Can a minor SMSF member make a binding nomination?
This depends on the member's legal capacity and the requirements of the trust deed. Some deeds restrict minors from making binding nominations, and a parent or guardian may not automatically be able to sign on their behalf.
Where a minor has a meaningful superannuation balance, the deed should be checked and legal advice obtained.
Can an attorney sign or renew a nomination?
Only where the trust deed and the relevant power of attorney permit it. The rules governing powers of attorney can also differ between states.
This is worth considering when preparing an enduring power of attorney, particularly where a member may lose capacity later in life.
How often should a binding nomination be reviewed?
At a minimum, review it annually and whenever there is a significant change in family, financial or business circumstances.
It should also be checked whenever the SMSF trust deed is updated.
Final thoughts: Make sure your SMSF nomination is still valid
A binding death benefit nomination is an important part of SMSF succession planning. It can provide certainty about who receives your superannuation, reduce the scope for disputes and help achieve a more tax-effective outcome for your family.
However, simply having a signed document is not enough. It must comply with the fund's trust deed, identify eligible beneficiaries and be properly executed and delivered to the trustee.
A good starting point is to put three documents together: the current SMSF trust deed, the latest binding death benefit nomination and the member's Will.
Check that the documents are consistent, the nominated beneficiaries are still eligible and any expiry provisions have been considered.
Need help reviewing your SMSF arrangements?
Guidance Accounting assists SMSF trustees with compliance, administration and identifying issues that could affect their fund. If you are unsure whether your binding death benefit nomination is valid or whether your fund's records are up to date, contact Guidance Accounting to discuss your situation.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and is not intended to be financial, legal, tax or personal advice. SMSF rules and individual circumstances can vary. The validity of a binding death benefit nomination depends on the fund's trust deed and applicable law. You should obtain appropriate legal, financial or tax advice before making or changing a nomination. Guidance Accounting accepts no responsibility for decisions made solely on the basis of this article.